Big call on Eels star's ban after controversial sin bin

Parramatta forward J'maine Hopgood has been hit with what will be a controversial ban by the NRL's match review committee.

Hopgood can accept a one-game suspension for an incident the MRC judged a grade two careless high tackle.

It happened when Storm forward Alec MacDonald fell into Hopgood's shoulder early in Thursday night's game at AAMI Park, leaving MacDonald concussed and out for the rest of the game.

READ MORE: Eels icon shuts down revenge theory behind Lomax collapse

READ MORE: Eels shellshocked as Storm rack up 52 in thumping

READ MORE: Former teammates clash as Swans rout Blues at SCG

It will no doubt cause a stir given Hopgood did little wrong, and actually got hit in the head himself.

On-field referee Todd Smith claimed it was "direct shoulder contact to the head" and the Bunker official agreed, sending Hopgood to the bin.

Replays seemed to show it was merely a head clash.

"What about his head?" Eels captain Mitchell Moses was heard asking, but Smith wanted none of it.

NRL legends Andrew Johns and Billy Slater agreed Hopgood had done nothing wrong.

"He was out before he hit the ground, MacDonald," Johns said on Nine.

Watch the 2026 NRL season live and free on Nine and 9Now.

"It's a head clash… I think the first contact is head on head.

"He is standing quite tall, Hopgood, and if anything it's the left-foot step of MacDonald (that results in the contact).

"It's accidental."

Storm icon Slater agreed.

"You can see J'maine Hopgood's head shake with the contact," Slater said.

It once again calls the consistency of the Bunker process and match review committee into question after Bulldogs captain Stephen Crichton last week avoided the bin and a charge despite his shoulder colliding with the head of Dragons rookie Setu Tu in Vegas.

Hopgood's was the only charge to stem from the game on Thursday.

That's despite his teammate Brian Kelly being penalised for a high tackle in the second half which Fox League commentator Andrew Voss suggested was worse than what Hopgood did.

Kelly was penalised but wasn't sin binned or charged over the incident.

Hopgood will miss next week's trip to Brisbane unless he can fight the charge at the NRL judiciary and win.

He may have a case to downgrade it to a grade one, which would wipe the suspension, after Penrith halfback Nathan Cleary did just that following a pre-season charge.